The lawyer is a Constitutional guarantee. The judge's gavel does not stand above the Constitution. The price of the GJKKO regulation is paid by the citizens.

By Attorney Xhoi Nela

Who is the new regulation of the GJKKO serving? The authority of a court stems from the ability to guarantee justice, to respect rights and to exercise power within the limits of the law. When an administrative regulation produces constant clashes with the legal profession, undeveloped hearings and punitive measures against defense attorneys, the question is inevitable, who is it serving?!

The lawyer is a constitutional guarantee because through him the citizen's right to defense becomes effective. Article 31 of the Constitution guarantees the time and facilities necessary for the preparation of the defense, the assistance of the chosen defense attorney and free and private communication with him. Article 42 guarantees due process. These guarantees determine the limits within which the court administration must also operate. An internal regulation must serve them. Therefore, opposing restrictions that violate the work of the LAWYER is a matter of protecting the citizen against state power. Whenever the conditions for exercising defense are weakened, justice itself is weakened.

The mobile phone, in the contemporary practice of law, is a working tool as it contains documents, professional communications, notifications and immediate coordination opportunities. The lawyer-client relationship requires continuity, responsibility and timely response. It does not cease the moment the lawyer enters a courthouse.

In my daily experience as a lawyer and that of my colleagues, hearings often last three hours (given the type of criminal offenses that this Court tries), the wait during the deliberations of the panel of judges can last another three hours. During this time, another client may be detained, the need for immediate legal assistance may arise, or a notification may arrive that requires urgent action. For the detained citizen, the chosen lawyer may be the only trusted contact who can activate his defense without delay. To deprive the lawyer of this opportunity for communication for hours means to violate his ability to respond to professional obligations. Availability for emergencies and for other clients requires organization that also respects the ongoing hearing. But a general ban, without functional alternatives, makes this responsibility impossible to fulfill.

The security and solemnity of the trial are legitimate goals. Precisely for this reason, justified measures are needed, such as: silent telephone, prohibition of unauthorized recordings, professional use and the possibility of urgent communication during breaks or waiting. Each restriction must explain the specific risk it avoids and the reason why a less restrictive measure is not sufficient. Here lies the responsibility of the management of the GJKKO and its president, to build an institutional solution to a conflict that affects the functioning of justice. Why has dialogue not yet been seen as a solution? Why is maintaining a regulation unchanged taking precedence over its consequences on the trial?

Administrative rigidity, when it persists despite obvious costs, creates the impression of a government that considers reviewing its decisions as a loss of authority. This is a dangerous way to understand public function. An institution gains credibility when it listens, reasons, and corrects.

Who are the successive fines against lawyers serving?

The documented fines show that the clash has already had direct financial consequences for the defenders. If the punishment is repeated while the institutional cause remains unresolved, it risks becoming a pressure on a profession that should exercise defense independently. The gavel symbolizes the responsibility to deliver justice. Holding it in the hand increases the obligation for self-restraint, reasoning and respect.

Those judges who, although in the minority, have assessed the legal obstacles to the defense and have not imposed fines on lawyers deserve recognition. In a climate of escalation, they have maintained moderation, independence of judgment and respect for human dignity. These are the judges we deserve, those who give weight to the word of the law and honor to the title they hold.

The issue becomes even more serious when the consequences fall on the freedom of the citizen. The case of Ilir Meta, according to his public statement, raises concerns about the suspension of detention terms while he has appeared in the hearings and has requested the continuation of the trial. Why should the citizen bear the cost of an institutional conflict that he did not create?

The law provides for cases of suspension of pre-trial detention periods, their implementation requires a legal basis and concrete justification. The presence of the defendant and the will to continue the process are circumstances that must be considered seriously. Article 5 of the ECHR guarantees trial within a reasonable time or release pending trial, as well as prompt judicial review of the legality of detention. Article 6 guarantees due process and legal aid for the defense. Suspension of the calculation of a term does not suspend the life of a person in pre-trial detention. The days continue to pass. Freedom lost during them is not restored through a delayed administrative solution!

Meanwhile, the institutional orientation for strengthening the legal profession has been clearly expressed. On October 6, 2026, during the presentation to the Law Commission of the Council of Europe Convention for the Protection of the Profession of Lawyer, in the context of its ratification, Minister of Justice Toni Gogu placed the emphasis on the independent lawyer as a guarantee for the effective protection of the citizen against the state.

Even the draft law on amendments to the Criminal Procedure Code, in the version presented, aims to strengthen the defense, access to evidence, intervention of the defense attorney during interrogation and the possibility of investigative activities in favor of the client. As a draft law, it does not yet constitute a law in force. But its spirit is clear, the defense attorney must have real means to exercise his role. It is difficult to reconcile this orientation with administrative practices that narrow and violate his working conditions.

🇪🇺The Council of Europe Convention for the Protection of the Profession of Lawyers links the protection of the profession to the rule of law and human rights. It provides for independence, protection from undue interference, and effective consultation of professional organizations on changes affecting the legal profession.

The OSCE's support should be read in the same spirit. In the meeting between Ambassador Michel Tarran and the President of the Chamber of Advocates, Maksim Haxhia, the role of the legal profession in strengthening the rule of law, access to justice, due process standards and the challenges of the profession were discussed. The expressed support for an accountable and effective justice system, in cooperation with the Chamber of Advocates, reinforces the need for institutional dialogue.

The situation is intolerable and requires a rapid response. The High Judicial Council, the management of the GJKKO and the Ministry of Justice, each within their respective competences, should establish a table with concrete deadlines for the review of the contested provisions and the restoration of the normal functioning of the processes. The High Inspector of Justice should assess any violation according to legal procedures and react with the authority that derives from the law.

The independence of the court and the independence of the lawyer are guarantees that must work together. The prolonged conflict between them is harming citizens, professionals and public trust in justice. Insistence on punishment (fines) without resolving this situation risks turning the judicial authority into an instrument of pressure on the defense!

The lawyer is a constitutional guarantee. Respecting him is respecting the citizen's right to defense. A justice system that demands public trust must demonstrate this in every rule, every hearing, and every decision.

Justice is not measured by the number of GJKKO fines, but by the ability to protect rights, to hear the voice of the defense and to correct any approach that harms the citizen. The judge's gavel should be a symbol of the law, not a tool of pressure, while the lawyer should be treated as a co-guarantor of justice, not as its opponent.

The conflict over the GJKKO regulation requires institutional dialogue and immediate solutions!

© BalkansWeb
To become part of the group "Balkanweb" just click: Join Group and your request will be approved immediately. Groups Balkanweb